A detailed article about the implications and concerns if the UK were to enact a single-embryo transfer policy for IVF procedures.
TwinWatch News: Britain may limit number of IVF embryos, and lots more news about multiples
I’ve gotten behind posting the news (sorry!), but there have been a lot of interesting articles lately, so here’s a quick run-down:
The top story today is about the possibility that women in Britain may soon be restricted to the implantation of one embryo during an IVF procedure. Currently, there are strict rules that restrict women under 40 to two embryos at a time, while women over 40 may have three. From the article:
The move to cut the number of embryos implanted follows research showing that multiple births are not only costly but put a mother’s health at risk and lead to a higher rate of disabilities in babies.
Twins and triplets are more likely to be born prematurely and be underweight. Triplets, for instance, are typically born at 34 or 35 weeks. There is also a greater risk that babies will be stillborn or suffer a long-term disability such as cerebral palsy.
Research from Sheffield University showed that families conceiving triplets by IVF cost the NHS £32,354 in their first year of life – 10 times the cost of a single baby – because of the health complications suffered by the mother and children. Currently, the twin birth rate is 23.6 per cent for mothers undergoing IVF, compared to between one per cent and two per cent in the general population.
But some fertility experts have warned that a one-embryo policy – adopted in the Netherlands, Finland and Sweden – would deprive tens of thousands of women the chance of having a baby.
The above news about the possibility of a limitation to a single embryo transfer in Britain has run in a number of British publications. Check out this editorial, written by a father of twins.
I love this article about a twinmom speaking up about her public transportation struggles. And, there’s a comment from a British twins club at the bottom of the article.
A very detailed article about the separation-in-school issue and the legislation wending its way through the Georgia legislature.
And, an editorial about the bill.
Article about four-year-old twins, separated in an orphanage in China and adopted by different sets of American parents, are reunited in Disney World.
Fun article about jazz-playing triplet teens.
A school in Mumbai, India has 13 sets of twins. Nice comments at the end of the article about whether to keep twins together in school.
TwinWatch News: Mia Hamm a twinmom
Dodgers first baseman Nomar Garciaparra and soccer star Mia Hamm are now parents of twin girls. The girls were born in Los Angeles on Tuesday, five weeks early.
TwinWatch News: Many IVF patients want twins; human ‘chimera’ discovered
Very interesting article about IVF. I’ve been reading about how many doctors are now encouraging IVF folks to implant one embryo instead of more than one. Apparently this is due to the higher risks for both mother and babes in multiples pregnancies and births. Turns out, according to this Boston Globe article, that many people still want twins because it ensures them of having more than one child.
Researchers have discovered twins who are neither identical nor fraternal; actually, they’re chimeras, a little of both. The twins are identical in terms of their mother’s genes, but they only have half of their father’s genes in common. Read the article on news@nature.com and blog posts in response at LiveScience.com and ScientificAmerican.com.
TwinWatch News: Canada’s first IVF twins turn 25; 50 years of marriage for twins married on same day
Sweet! Twin sisters Grace Stokes and Elspeth Hall, 70, had a double wedding and are now celebrating their 50th anniversaries. They even received a letter from Queen Elizabeth because of their special story. My favorite part of the article:
Elspeth said: “We did think we might have separate ceremonies as we wanted to be married at different times of the year.
“But my dad told us, ‘You came into the house together, so you should leave the house together’ – and that was it’.”
Another anniversary, this one from Canada.com: Colin and Gregory Rankin are Canada’s first IVF twins. They just turned 25. From the article:
In Canada alone, there are now 28 IVF clinics across the country, and the 2004 numbers – the latest available – show that almost 2,000 babies were born through IVF that year.
But for Colin and Greg, who are planning to go on a road trip later this summer to make up for their lacklustre 25th birthday celebration, the significance of their birth is enough to make them a bit philosophical at times.
“Hundreds of thousands of babies are born through IVF every year, and it’s crazy to think we were one of the first,” Colin said.
“But if you think about it, anybody being born and turning out the way they are is a one-in-a-million chance, so I think Greg and I being born is just one out of a billion – just a few zeros away.”
TwinWatch News: Twins in anorexia research study; twin hockey stars; triplet gardeners
Research using twins and other multiples contributes much to the understanding of human behavior. (You can read my interview with a University of Southern California twin researcher here on BeTwinned.com.) This news story gives an example of a pair of twins who are participating in a National Institutes of Health study about eating disorders and genetics. Both twins suffer from anorexia.
I read stories all the time about twins and triplets excelling in athletics. Here’s one about 26-year-old twin hockey-playing brothers Daniel and Henrik Sedin. They play for the Vancouver Canucks.
I absolutely love this story about gardening triplets. At the end of the article, the triplets’ mother gives a series of tips about getting kids interested in gardening.
TwinWatch news: Same classroom legislation in Georgia; new test may reduce number of IVF multiples conceptions
Whew. Be sure to check out this Atlanta Journal-Constitution article about Georgia’s legislature debating a bill that would allow parents to have a choice about putting twins in the same classroom. Don’t miss the comments underneath the article for some fascinating glimpses of ignorance in the electorate. Here’s an example:
Wow. A state law for one complaining mother in one school in one county. Gotyourhandsfull is right. I’ve known many parents of mulitples who preferred to have their children split up to encourage individuality. Where’s their law? This one mandates twins be kept together if the parents want it, but there’s no provision for parents requesting separate classrooms.
A mere 40 days to handle all legislative business for the year, and this nonsense makes it to the floor. The authors of the bill and all committee members who voted to send it on up the ladder should be impeached!
Uh, guess this person misunderstood the part of the bill that states that twins and multiples should be in the same classroom “if the parent or guardian requests” it.
Kudos to Kathy Dolan for bringing clarity to that discussion.
>>>>>>
In other news, researchers from Yale and Canada’s McGill University have made a discovery that may make it possible to determine which IVF candidate embryos have the best possibility of success. This would mean that doctors would only implant one embryo at a time, obviously reducing the numbers of twin and triplet conceptions.
TwinWatch news: Twins pair up for charity; Valerie Plame a twin mom
I love this Tallahassee Democrat story about Florida State twins, both medical students, who started a charity drive called “Share a Pair.” They collect shoes to send to needy children around the world.
And, in other news, it turns out that Valerie Plame is a twin mom! I cracked up reading this blog post about her defending her claim that she had not used nepotism to send her husband on assignment to Nigers.
Twins in school: My always-together girls
My husband and I took our three-and-a-half year old daughters to a little “play date” session at a local private school. Really, of course, this play date was an admissions event.
Already, I have a number of reservations about applying to private schools. I grew up going to public schools, and overall, I got a fine education. I realize I was lucky and that I grew up in neighborhoods with good schools.
Additionally, private schools are expensive, and my husband and I hover in that middle range of the middle class where we don’t make enough to send our kids to private schools, and we don’t fall into the range of people who qualify for financial aid.
But, we live in the Los Angeles area, where good public schools are few and far between, so we have to hedge our bets and explore lots of options for the time being. At least we live in a neighborhood where the public school has a good reputation. So, my husband and I agreed to just check out all the possibilities and watch where the chips fall.
So that’s how we found ourselves at the crack of dawn on a Saturday morning, taking our kids to meet strangers who would be evaluating their academic and social prowess.
This particular school has a stellar reputation, and a number of friends of mine have sent their kids there. I also have a number of former students who have gone to this school, all with the same rave reviews.
So I went with the best expectations.
When we got there, we were invited into a large multi-purpose room where there was friendly kiddie music playing. The kids were all playing with the giant blocks and having a nice time.
I watched as a teacher approached Dinah and asked her to come with her. Suddenly, seeing this teacher approach only Dinah, I realized that they were going to separate the girls for the session.
I went up to the teacher and asked if this were the case. She wasn’t even aware that there were twins coming! And she said that yes, they probably were going to be separated, and that if they came to the school, they would probably be separated then too.
Now, as a teacher and a parenting writer who regularly receives electronic news feeds about twins and multiples, I am a double ringer. So, I decided not to make too big an issue out of it. After all, I figured, maybe Dinah and Djuna would do fine being separated. Who knew?
But, I couldn’t help thinking, that the current trend is not to separate twins in school. There is even a law being proposed in New Hampshire that would prohibit schools from automatically separating twins in school. (Read here for more information.)
The kids all eventually scampered out with their respective teachers, and it was hard to see, in all the hustle-bustle, just which kids were with which teachers.
Dwayne and I waited in the room with the other parents, and the kiddie music continued to play in the background. We chatted with a family we knew, but I was distracted, thinking that my always-together girls would be apart.
In fact, they were separated. The parents were invited to wander through the school for a bit, and we caught sight of Dinah and Djuna at different times in the playground. They seemed content enough, but somehow sedate, not my sparky, sparkly daughters.
As a teacher, I get it. I know that the teachers only wanted to see the girls in their individual state. That’s OK. But would you say to a tiny, young individual, “You know, we want to see how you do this try-out session without your right arm. If you are truly strong and smart, you’ll figure out how to cope without that arm. You have another one, after all.” The cherished all-American value of independence is different for tiny twins.
How can I explain to people who don’t have twins that being a twin is an integral part of their existence? That when I was in the hospital with one daughter when she was one-and-a-half that she woke in the night, calling for her twin? That on the few occasions when we have separated and done different things with the girls, that they run to each other and hug when they are reunited? That they have a multitude of jokes that only they understand?
Things are different as twins grow older, I’m sure, and I know that different twins have different needs too. But, shouldn’t teachers at least ask what’s best for my twins? Funnily enough, without my husband and I asking the girls specifically, they have both told us that they missed each other yesterday morning.
It made me have a newfound appreciation for Mama Pete, the woman who runs the girls’ current preschool. She’s over 90 years old and has been running her preschool for over 50 years. In her holiday card to us, she wrote something along this line: “Dinah and Djuna still pretty much stick together, but that’s completely appropriate for twins at their age.”
Thanks for your wisdom, Mama Pete.
TwinWatch News: Tyra Banks show to host conjoined twins
Tyra Banks recently taped a show about conjoined twins that is expected to air February 15. These two articles, one from the Litchfield County Times and the other from Canada.com, both tell the stories of conjoined twins who participated in the taping.